Compare Car Insurance Rates in Ohio
See if you qualify for a lower rate in less than 2 minutes
What Is Jerry and How Does It Work?
Jerry is not an insurance company. It's a licensed digital insurance broker (Jerry Insurance Agency, LLC) operating in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. Since launching its comparison service in January 2019, Jerry has grown to more than 5 million users and become one of the top three digital brokers in the U.S. by policies sold.
The app uses AI and machine learning to pull real-time quotes from 50 to 100+ carriers (Progressive, Nationwide, Travelers, AAA, and many non-standard insurers), then lets you compare, buy, and switch policies inside the app. It's part of a broader "automotive super app" that also handles auto loan refinancing, maintenance reminders, and a driver-safety telematics feature called DriveShield.
The four-step Jerry flow
- Sign up in about five minutes by answering questions about you, your vehicle, and your current coverage.
- Compare up to 20 side-by-side quotes from participating insurers.
- Buy the policy in the app and pay monthly or upfront.
- Jerry cancels your old policy and re-shops your rate every renewal.
If you already use one of the best car insurance mobile apps, Jerry adds a shopping layer on top of your existing carrier relationship rather than replacing it.
Compare Car Insurance Rates in Ohio
See if you qualify for a lower rate in less than 2 minutes
How Jerry Makes Money (and Whether It's Really Free)
The short answer: downloading and using Jerry is free. You are not charged a broker fee by Jerry itself. Instead, Jerry earns a standard commission from the insurance company when you buy a policy through the app, plus recurring commissions each time that policy renews. Jerry has stated that it does not mark up carrier prices.
Additional revenue streams include:
- Auto loan refinancing fees from lender partners (users reportedly save about $150/month on average when they refinance).
- Repair marketplace referral fees when you book service through the app.
- Telematics and driver-safety programs that connect users to discount-eligible carriers.
What data Jerry collects
To generate accurate quotes, Jerry collects:
- Personal ID and contact info (name, email, phone)
- Vehicle and current policy details
- A credit score range (used for pricing in most states)
- Optional driving telematics if you opt into DriveShield
Jerry's public "DataLock" promise says it does not sell your data to telemarketers or share it with third parties for marketing. Driving tracking is opt-in only, and a company representative on Reddit has publicly stated that Jerry does not sell or share driving data.
Protect your car with Farmers
Average Rate:
Find coverage options that fit your budget.
The insurance savings you expect.
Average Rate:
Enjoy personalized policies, comprehensive coverage & more.
See how much you could save today!
Average Rate:
Drivers who switch their auto insurance and save with State Farm save $764 on average!
Safe Drivers Save with Allstate®
Average Rate:
Get rewarded with savings for having a clean driving record.
Does Jerry Actually Save You Money?
Jerry's own site claims drivers who switch save an average of $853/year on full coverage and $1,037/year on minimum coverage, based on customers with clean records who found savings. Press materials also cite a broader $600/year average.
Independent reviews and real user testimonials paint a more nuanced picture:
| Source | Reported Outcome |
|---|---|
| Apple App Store review | Saved $150-$200/month on same coverage |
| Trustpilot (heavy user) | Cut $1,400/month down to under $500 for three cars |
| Motley Fool test | Same GEICO policy $90/mo via Jerry vs. $110/mo direct |
| Reddit user | About $420/year savings on annual policy |
| 2025 video review | Notes savings are not guaranteed for everyone |
For most people, the honest expectation is: if you haven't shopped for car insurance in the past 12-24 months, Jerry can realistically surface three-figure annual savings. If you're already optimized, the app may simply confirm your rate is good.
Jerry vs. The Zebra, Insurify, and Gabi
All four are legit comparison tools, but they solve different problems.
| Platform | Carriers | Best For | Notable Weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jerry | 50-100+ | Hands-off switching via app | App-only access; billing complaints |
| The Zebra | 100+ | Fast web quotes + education | Final price can drift 5-25% higher |
| Insurify | 120+ | Accuracy and AI matching | Phone number often required |
| Gabi | 40+ | Monitoring your current policy | Smaller carrier pool |
Ratings snapshot: Trustpilot rates Jerry around 4.6/5 and Apple App Store 4.7/5, while the BBB average is a more modest 3.6-3.8/5. Insurify and The Zebra sit at similar Trustpilot marks (4.6-4.7), while Gabi trails around 3.5/5.
If you want to see how a fully app-native insurer compares to a broker like Jerry, our Lemonade car insurance review and Root car insurance review both dig into pay-per-mile and behavior-based pricing.
Pros, Cons, and Red Flags
Red flags to watch
- Quote-to-bind price drift. Multiple BBB complaints allege that the final price after entering payment info was significantly higher than the initial quote. Screenshot every quote before you pay.
- Cancellation friction. Some users say phone support was unreachable and chats were closed before issues were resolved. If you cancel, confirm directly with your old and new carrier in writing.
- Refunds for unused days. At least one Google Play reviewer reports being unable to secure a promised prorated refund without escalation.
- App-only workflow. You can start on the web, but you'll be pushed to the app to finalize.
Who Should (and Shouldn't) Use Jerry
Best fit:
- Busy shoppers who don't want to enter their info on five different sites.
- Drivers overpaying because they haven't re-shopped in over a year.
- High-risk drivers (SR-22, DUI, lapses, tickets) who benefit from Jerry's non-standard carrier network that traditional big-name comparison tools skip.
- Renewal-averse drivers who want automatic re-shopping every six months.
Skip Jerry if:
- You already have a competitive rate with a major insurer.
- You strongly prefer working with a local human agent.
- You dislike installing apps or granting permissions on your phone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Jerry car insurance legit and licensed? Yes. Jerry Insurance Agency, LLC is a licensed insurance broker in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. It is not an insurance carrier itself, so any policy you buy is underwritten by a partner insurer such as Progressive, Nationwide, or Travelers. Jerry has served over 5 million customers since 2019 and holds an A+ BBB accreditation.
Does Jerry charge hidden fees? Jerry itself does not charge broker fees. However, some users report that carrier-imposed fees (SR-22 filings, installment charges, state surcharges) appear at checkout and can make the final premium higher than the initial quote. Always confirm the full monthly and annual total on the insurer's own confirmation page before paying.
How does Jerry cancel my old insurance policy? After you buy a new policy in the app, Jerry contacts your prior insurer to submit a cancellation request, timing the effective date to avoid a coverage gap. You should still call your old carrier to confirm the cancellation date in writing and request any prorated refund directly from them, since this step occasionally fails.
How is Jerry different from The Zebra or Insurify? Jerry is app-first and acts as your ongoing broker, automatically re-shopping your rate at renewal and handling the switch. The Zebra and Insurify are web-first quote tools with larger carrier networks (100-120+) but do not manage your policy for you. Insurify tends to be the most accurate, The Zebra is best for education, and Jerry is best for hands-off automation.
Is Jerry good for high-risk drivers or SR-22 policies? Jerry can be especially useful for high-risk drivers because its carrier network includes non-standard insurers that many mainstream comparison sites don't feature. That means drivers with DUIs, at-fault accidents, or coverage lapses may find quotes they couldn't get elsewhere. Just be sure to verify SR-22 filing fees and effective dates directly with the issuing carrier.