Compare Home Insurance Plans in Ohio
Find your best options in less than 2 minutes
What Is Hippo Home Insurance?
Hippo launched in 2015 with a bold promise: to modernize homeowners insurance by making it faster, smarter, and more proactive than traditional carriers. Instead of the reactive, paper-heavy model that most legacy insurers use, Hippo built its model around technology — offering instant online quotes, smart home device integration, and proactive monitoring tools designed to help prevent claims before they happen.
Unlike many companies that both sell and underwrite policies, Hippo operates as an insurtech platform. Policies are underwritten by partner carriers — most notably Spinnaker Insurance Company and Topa Insurance Company — both rated A- (Excellent) by AM Best. This means Hippo handles the customer experience and technology while licensed, financially strong carriers back your actual policy.
Hippo offers homeowners insurance across 37+ states, and has expanded its distribution through a partnership with Progressive in select markets including Texas, Georgia, Illinois, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Colorado.
Coverage Options at a Glance
Hippo structures its policies into three tiers, giving you flexibility based on your needs and budget:
| Tier | What's Included |
|---|---|
| Essentials | Dwelling, personal property, liability, loss of use |
| Best Value | Everything in Essentials + water backup, extended reconstruction costs |
| Expanded Protection | Everything in Best Value + higher limits, service line coverage |
All tiers include higher-than-average limits for electronics, home office equipment, computers, and appliances — a deliberate choice that reflects the realities of modern home ownership. Hippo also offers coverage for HOA-related losses in select states.
Compare Home Insurance Plans in Ohio
Find your best options in less than 2 minutes
Hippo's Smart Technology & Proactive Risk Management
This is where Hippo truly differentiates itself from both traditional insurers and other insurtechs. Rather than waiting for something to go wrong, Hippo's model is built around preventing losses in the first place.
Smart Home Integration
When you sign up for a Hippo policy in eligible states, you may receive a free smart home kit that includes:
- Water leak sensors — detect moisture before it becomes major water damage
- Smoke and CO detectors — early warning for fire-related losses
- Entry sensors and security cameras (from brands like SimpliSafe and Ring)
Activating these devices qualifies you for ongoing premium discounts and feeds into Hippo's risk reduction model — the idea being that an informed homeowner is less likely to file a claim.
Hippo's Proactive Risk Philosophy
Hippo's approach to risk management is notably different from legacy carriers. The company uses AI-driven underwriting tools and real-time data signals to assess risk more accurately and dynamically. It has also implemented selective underwriting practices — including rate adjustments, higher wind/hail deductibles in vulnerable regions, and non-renewals in the highest-risk areas — to keep the portfolio financially healthy.
This risk-first mentality has shown financial results: Hippo posted $58 million in net income in 2025 versus a loss the prior year, with its combined ratio improving by 25 points year-over-year.
For a comparison with another digital-first carrier, check out our Lemonade home insurance review to see how these two insurtechs stack up.
Protect your home with State Farm
Average Rate:
Homeowners who bundle and save with State Farm save an average of $1,000 per year!
You're in Good Hands® with Allstate
Average Rate:
Get comprehensive home coverage with flexible policy options.
Customize your home coverage
Average Rate:
Only pay for the coverage you need with personalized home insurance.
Smart coverage for your home
Average Rate:
Protect what matters most with award-winning home insurance.
Hippo Home Insurance: Pros, Cons & Customer Ratings
Customer Ratings Summary (2026)
Hippo's ratings are a tale of two extremes. Its mobile apps are well-loved, while third-party review platforms tell a more sobering story:
| Rating Source | Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| BBB (Business Rating) | A+ | Accredited; reflects business practices |
| BBB (Customer Reviews) | 1.08 / 5 | Mostly 1-star; premium hikes, claims issues |
| Trustpilot | ~2.1 / 5 | Mixed; low overall satisfaction |
| The Zebra | 1 / 5 | Subpar satisfaction ratings |
| Apple App Store | 4.8 / 5 | Praised for ease of use and maintenance alerts |
| Google Play | 4.4 / 5 | Positive feedback on quote speed and UX |
The disconnect between app ratings and review platform scores is significant. Customers who interact with Hippo digitally tend to be satisfied — it's when claims and billing disputes arise that frustration spikes.
Common Complaints
The most frequently reported issues in 2025–2026 include:
- Premium increases — Some customers reported premiums more than doubling at renewal with little explanation
- Claims delays — Reports of waits lasting months for adjuster reports, engineer inspections, or reimbursement funds
- Poor communication — Adjusters described as unresponsive; claims reportedly getting "lost" or requiring multiple resubmissions
- Denial disputes — Some policyholders reported coverage denials for events they believed were covered (e.g., power surge damage)
Hippo's Pros and Cons
Hippo vs. Lemonade vs. Traditional Insurers
Both Hippo and Lemonade are insurtechs targeting homeowners who prefer a digital experience over working with agents. But they take meaningfully different approaches.
| Feature | Hippo | Lemonade | Traditional Insurer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Online Quote Speed | ~60 seconds | ~90 seconds | Varies (agent may be required) |
| Smart Home Discounts | ✅ Yes — 10+ discount types | ❌ Limited | ❌ Rarely |
| Water Backup (Base Policy) | ✅ Included in mid/top tiers | ❌ Add-on cost | ❌ Add-on cost |
| Auto Bundling | ❌ Not available | ✅ Available | ✅ Usually available |
| Claims Filing | Phone/app | App only | Agent or phone |
| State Availability | 37+ states | 23+ states | Varies |
| Financial Backing | A- (via partners) | A (via reinsurance) | Varies |
Key takeaway: Hippo is better suited for tech-savvy homeowners who want proactive protection and don't need auto bundling. Lemonade may appeal to those who want an even simpler, fully app-driven experience with bundling options. If you want the reliability of a long-established carrier with a proven claims track record, consider reviewing our Progressive homeowners insurance review or our Geico home insurance review.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is Hippo home insurance good?
Hippo is a solid option for tech-forward homeowners who value digital convenience, smart home discounts, and proactive protection tools. Its policies are backed by A- rated carriers, and pricing tends to run below industry averages. However, mixed customer service and claims handling reviews mean it may not be ideal for those who prioritize hands-on support during the claims process.
What states does Hippo home insurance operate in?
Hippo is licensed in 37+ states including Texas, California, Colorado, Georgia, Illinois, Arizona, and many others. It does not currently offer policies in all 50 states, and availability can change. Always check Hippo's website or call directly to confirm availability in your state before starting a quote.
How much does Hippo home insurance cost?
Hippo policies average approximately $1,761 per year, which is roughly 17% below the national industry average of ~$2,490/year for comparable coverage. Your actual premium will vary based on your home's location, age, size, roof condition, claims history, and which tier of coverage you select.
How does Hippo compare to Lemonade home insurance?
Both are insurtechs offering fast digital quotes, but Hippo's strength is in proactive risk tools and smart home integration — with 10+ discount categories and free device kits. Lemonade has an edge in bundling (it also offers renters, pet, life, and auto coverage) and offers a fully app-driven claims process. Neither currently ranks in J.D. Power's top home insurance companies.
What are the most common Hippo home insurance complaints?
The most frequently reported complaints involve sharp premium increases at renewal (some exceeding 100%), delays in claims processing (sometimes lasting several months), poor adjuster communication, and disputes over claim denials. These are most common in high-risk states. Hippo's NAIC complaint index has historically been below industry average, but BBB and Trustpilot reviews from 2025–2026 reflect rising frustrations with the claims experience.