Farmers Home Insurance Review: Coverage, Cost & Customer Service

Is Farmers homeowners insurance worth the cost? We break down rates, coverage, and who it's best for.

Updated Apr 28, 2026 Fact checked

Compare Home Insurance Plans in Ohio

Find your best options in less than 2 minutes

Farmers Insurance is one of the largest and most recognized homeowners insurance providers in the United States, offering a broad range of coverage options backed by a network of over 18,000 local agents. But with average premiums running above the national average, is the added cost worth it?

In this review, we break down Farmers' homeowners insurance costs by state, available coverage options, unique policy features, available discounts, claims satisfaction data, and financial strength ratings. By the end, you'll know exactly whether Farmers is the right carrier for your home — and how to get the best possible rate if it is.

Key Pinch Points

  • Farmers' national average premium is ~$3,250/yr, above the $2,490 industry average
  • Bundle home and auto to save an average of $1,232 per year with Farmers
  • AM Best rates Farmers' core property entities A (Excellent) for financial strength
  • Declining deductible drops your out-of-pocket costs $50 for each claim-free year

Compare Home Insurance Plans in Ohio

Find your best options in less than 2 minutes

Coverage Options: What Does Farmers Home Insurance Cover?

Farmers homeowners insurance starts with a solid foundation of standard protections that apply to virtually every policy. Understanding what's included — and what you can add on — is the first step to knowing whether Farmers is the right fit for your home.

Standard Coverage Inclusions

Every Farmers homeowners policy includes the following core protections:

Coverage Type What It Protects
Dwelling The physical structure of your home
Other Structures Detached garages, fences, sheds
Personal Property Your belongings inside the home
Loss of Use Temporary living expenses if your home is uninhabitable
Personal Liability Legal expenses if someone is injured on your property
Medical Payments Guest injury medical costs regardless of fault

Optional Add-Ons and Unique Features

Where Farmers really stands out is in its optional coverage enhancements. These allow homeowners to build a policy tailored to their specific risks and lifestyle:

  • Guaranteed/Extended Replacement Cost — Pays up to 25% above your dwelling limit if rebuilding costs exceed your policy limits, protecting against construction cost surges
  • Equipment Breakdown Coverage — Covers sudden mechanical or electrical failures of appliances and home systems not normally covered by standard policies
  • Identity Theft Protection (Identity Shield) — Provides financial protection and recovery services if your personal information is compromised
  • Water Backup Coverage — Protects against damage from sewer or sump pump backups
  • Roof Replacement Upgrade — Allows you to rebuild with stronger roofing materials after a loss
  • Homeshare Coverage — Designed for Airbnb-style short-term rental hosts
  • Emergency Mortgage Assistance — Covers up to three months or $10,000 in mortgage payments if your home becomes uninhabitable
  • Scheduled Personal Property — Extra coverage for high-value items like jewelry, art, or instruments
  • Building Ordinance or Law Coverage — Pays the added cost of bringing your home up to current building codes after a covered loss

Pros

  • Generous optional add-ons including equipment breakdown and identity theft
  • Guaranteed replacement cost up to 25% above dwelling limit
  • Unique perks like declining deductible and claim forgiveness
  • Bundling discounts up to 22% when combining home and auto

Cons

  • Average rates run higher than State Farm, Allstate, and Travelers
  • Below-average J.D. Power claims satisfaction score
  • Not available in all states; no longer writing new policies in Florida
  • BBB customer reviews are notably low

Policy Types Available

Farmers doesn't just cover single-family homes. Their policy lineup includes:

  • Single-family homeowners insurance
  • Condo insurance
  • Mobile/manufactured home insurance
  • Rental property insurance
  • Seasonal/vacation home insurance
  • Older home insurance

Note: Standard Farmers policies do not cover flood or earthquake damage. These require separate policies, which Farmers can help you obtain through partner programs.

Pincher's Pro Tip

New home? You could save up to 34%. Farmers automatically applies a new home discount for homes less than 14 years old — one of the largest new-home discounts in the industry. Always ask your agent what discounts apply to your specific property.

Trusted by Thousands

Compare Home Insurance Plans in Ohio

Find your best options in less than 2 minutes

Takes 2 min
100% Free
Secure

Farmers Home Insurance Cost by State

One of the most critical factors shoppers consider is price. Farmers' national average sits at approximately $3,250 per year — roughly $760 above the industry average of $2,490. However, rates vary dramatically by location, home value, and risk profile.

Average Annual Premiums by State (Based on $300K Dwelling Coverage)

State Farmers Annual Rate
Wisconsin $1,694
Utah $1,696
California $1,926
Pennsylvania $1,774
Oregon $1,860
Washington $1,989
Nevada $1,992
Idaho $2,187
Arizona $2,523
Virginia $2,440
Minnesota $2,693
Connecticut $2,935
Michigan $2,884
North Dakota $2,966
Iowa $3,017
New York $3,043
Illinois $3,331
New Mexico $3,336
Indiana $3,133
Georgia $3,174
Kansas $3,982
Nebraska $4,137
Missouri $4,173
Montana $4,133
Colorado $6,504
Oklahoma $9,432

States with the highest Farmers rates — like Oklahoma, Colorado, and Texas — reflect elevated risks from tornadoes, hailstorms, and wildfires. Meanwhile, low-risk states like Wisconsin and Utah offer some of the most competitive rates in Farmers' portfolio.

How Farmers Compares to Competitors

Farmers Insurance

  • ~$3,250/yr national average
  • Up to 22% bundle discount
  • A (Excellent) AM Best rating
  • Below-avg J.D. Power claims score
  • Local agent model

Competitors

  • State Farm ~$2,415/yr
  • Allstate ~$2,715/yr
  • Travelers ~$2,710/yr
  • Am. Family ~$4,235/yr
  • USAA ~$1,940/yr (military only)

For context, check out our full best home insurance companies guide to see how Farmers ranks among all major national carriers.

Rate Accuracy Warning

The rates shown are averages based on $300,000 in dwelling coverage with a $1,000 deductible. Your actual quote will vary based on your home's age, construction type, claims history, credit score, and ZIP code. Always get a personalized quote before making a decision.

State Farm logo

Protect your home with State Farm

Average Rate:

$ 125 /mo

Homeowners who bundle and save with State Farm save an average of $1,000 per year!

Allstate logo

You're in Good Hands® with Allstate

Average Rate:

$ 125 /mo

Get comprehensive home coverage with flexible policy options.

Liberty Mutual logo

Customize your home coverage

Average Rate:

$ 125 /mo

Only pay for the coverage you need with personalized home insurance.

Farmers logo

Smart coverage for your home

Average Rate:

$ 125 /mo

Protect what matters most with award-winning home insurance.

Discounts, Bundling & Financial Strength

Available Discounts

Farmers is frequently recognized for its broad discount menu. Here are the key ways to reduce your premium:

Discount Potential Savings
New Home (under 14 years old) Up to 34%
Home + Auto Bundle Up to 22% avg.
Protective Devices (smoke detectors, sprinkler systems) Varies by state
UL-Approved Roofing Materials Varies
Hail-Resistant Roof Varies
ePolicy / Paperless Enrollment Varies
Paid-in-Full Premium ~3%
Non-Smoker Discount Varies
Loyalty Discount Varies
Prior Renters Insurance (1+ year) Varies

Pincher's Pro Tip

Bundle and save big. Farmers reports that customers who bundle home and auto save an average of $1,232 per year (based on data from 9/1/24–8/31/25). That's among the highest bundle savings of any major national carrier. Learn more about home and auto bundling strategies.

Farmers' Loyalty Perks

Beyond standard discounts, Farmers rewards long-term customers with two standout features:

  • Declining Deductible: Your deductible drops by $50 for every year your policy remains claim-free — helping reduce your out-of-pocket costs over time
  • Claim Forgiveness: After a qualifying period of claim-free history, your first claim will not trigger a rate increase

Financial Strength Ratings

A key question when choosing any insurer is: will they actually be able to pay when I file a claim? Farmers' core property and casualty entities hold an AM Best Financial Strength Rating of A (Excellent), backed by parent company Zurich Insurance Group. This rating reflects excellent capacity to meet policyholder obligations and provides strong confidence in Farmers' long-term stability.


Compare Home Insurance Plans in Ohio

Find your best options in less than 2 minutes

Customer Satisfaction, Claims & Who Farmers Is Best For

Customer Satisfaction & Claims Reviews

Farmers receives a mixed but informative picture across major rating sources:

Rating Source Score / Finding
J.D. Power 2025 Home Insurance Study Below industry average (676 vs. 682 avg.)
J.D. Power 2025 Property Claims Study 691/1,000 — ranked 10th
Insure.com 2026 Consumer Survey 4.00/5 — ranked #5 nationally
Claims Handling (Insure.com) 76% satisfaction
Customer Renewal Rate 93% plan to renew
Would Recommend Farmers 88% of surveyed customers
BBB Customer Reviews 1.09/5 (440 reviews)

While J.D. Power scores suggest below-average satisfaction — especially around claims — Insure.com's broader consumer survey paints a more positive picture, with 93% of Farmers customers planning to renew. The disconnect likely reflects that satisfied customers are less likely to leave online reviews, while frustrated claimants are more vocal.

Common positive feedback highlights Farmers' knowledgeable local agents and policy flexibility. Common complaints center around rate increases, claims delays, and communication gaps during the claims process.

Local Agent Model vs. Online-First Competitors

Farmers operates through a network of 18,000+ local agents across the U.S. This stands in sharp contrast to digital-first competitors like Lemonade, which use AI-driven platforms for instant quotes and automated claims.

Farmers (Agent Model)

  • Personalized guidance from local agents
  • Complex coverage customization
  • Strong financial backing (AM Best A)
  • Slower digital experience
  • Higher average premiums

Online-First (e.g., Lemonade)

  • No local agent support
  • Limited complex coverage options
  • Newer, less proven financial track record
  • Instant AI-powered quotes
  • Lower starting premiums

For homeowners with complex coverage needs, high-value properties, or older homes, the agent-driven model offers real advantages. For renters or first-time buyers with straightforward needs, an online competitor like Lemonade may offer a faster, cheaper starting point.

Who Should Choose Farmers Home Insurance?

Farmers is best suited for:

  • Homeowners who want highly customized coverage with a wide range of add-ons
  • Buyers with newer homes who can capitalize on the up to 34% new home discount
  • Households looking to bundle home and auto for meaningful long-term savings
  • Homeowners who prefer working with a dedicated local agent for personalized guidance
  • Those in lower-risk states where Farmers' rates are competitive (e.g., Wisconsin, Utah, Pennsylvania)

Farmers may NOT be the best fit if:

  • You're primarily focused on finding the lowest possible premium
  • You prefer a fully digital, self-service experience
  • You live in a state where Farmers has limited availability (e.g., Florida)
  • Customer service consistency is a top priority

For a head-to-head comparison against other top carriers, see our State Farm vs. Allstate comparison guide.


Smart Savings Made Simple!

Compare Home Insurance Plans in Ohio

Find your best options in less than 2 minutes

Frequently Asked Questions About Farmers Home Insurance

Is Farmers a good home insurance company?

Farmers is a solid choice for homeowners who want flexible, customizable coverage and value a local agent relationship. It earns an A (Excellent) AM Best financial strength rating and offers one of the most comprehensive menus of optional coverages in the industry. However, its premiums run above the national average, and J.D. Power claims satisfaction scores are below industry average — so it may not be the ideal fit for budget-focused shoppers.

How much does Farmers home insurance cost per month?

Farmers' national average sits around $3,250 per year, which works out to approximately $271 per month. However, costs vary widely by state — from as low as $141/month in Wisconsin to over $785/month in Oklahoma. Factors like your home's age, location, claims history, and the coverage options you choose will all affect your final rate.

Does Farmers offer a home and auto bundle discount?

Yes. Farmers offers one of the most valuable bundling programs among major insurers. Customers who combine home and auto policies can save up to 22% on average, with Farmers reporting average bundle savings of approximately $1,232 per year. Bundling additional policies like umbrella or life insurance can extend your savings further.

What makes Farmers home insurance unique compared to other carriers?

Farmers differentiates itself through features like the Declining Deductible (your deductible drops $50 for each claim-free year), Claim Forgiveness (no rate hike after your first claim), guaranteed replacement cost coverage up to 25% above your dwelling limit, equipment breakdown protection, and identity theft coverage. These features, combined with a robust local agent network, set Farmers apart from both traditional and digital-first competitors.

How do I get a Farmers home insurance quote?

You can get a Farmers quote online at Farmers.com or by contacting a local Farmers agent directly. To get an accurate quote, have the following information ready: your home's age, square footage, construction type, current roof condition, your preferred dwelling coverage amount, deductible preference, and any desired add-ons. Comparing quotes from at least 2–3 insurers is always recommended to ensure you're getting competitive pricing for your coverage level.

Compare Home Insurance Plans in Ohio

Find your best options in less than 2 minutes

Get Free Quotes
Secure & Private Takes 2 minutes No obligation