Compare Car Insurance Rates in Ohio
See if you qualify for a lower rate in less than 2 minutes
What Is Comprehensive Car Insurance?
Comprehensive car insurance is an optional coverage that protects your vehicle from non-collision damages, often called "other than collision" coverage. This protection covers a wide range of incidents beyond typical accidents, including theft, vandalism, natural disasters, and animal strikes.
When you purchase comprehensive car insurance, your policy pays up to your vehicle's actual cash value (ACV) minus your chosen deductible. This coverage works independently from your collision insurance, though they're often purchased together as part of full coverage car insurance.
How Comprehensive Coverage Works
When you file a comprehensive claim, your insurance company assesses the damage and determines the repair cost or replacement value. You pay your deductible first, then the insurer covers the remaining amount up to your vehicle's ACV. For example, if a tree falls on your car causing $3,500 in damage and you have a $500 deductible, your insurer pays $3,000.
The most common comprehensive insurance claims include animal collisions (particularly deer strikes), glass damage, theft or stolen parts like catalytic converters, and weather-related incidents. These events happen unexpectedly and are typically beyond your control as a driver.
Compare Car Insurance Rates in Ohio
See if you qualify for a lower rate in less than 2 minutes
Comprehensive vs Collision Insurance: Understanding the Difference
Many drivers confuse comprehensive vs collision insurance, but these coverages protect against distinctly different scenarios. Understanding this distinction helps you make informed decisions about which protection you need.
When Each Coverage Applies
Comprehensive coverage applies when your vehicle sustains damage from events outside a traditional collision. If a hailstorm damages your roof and hood, comprehensive handles it. If you swerve to avoid debris and roll your vehicle, that's collision coverage territory.
Both coverages are optional unless you finance or lease your vehicle. Lenders typically require both comprehensive and collision insurance to protect their investment until you pay off the loan. Once you own your vehicle outright, you can choose to carry one, both, or neither—though liability car insurance remains mandatory in most states.
The key distinction: comprehensive protects against uncontrollable external factors, while collision covers driver-related incidents and impacts. You can have one without the other, but most insurers recommend both for optimal protection.
Protect your car with Progressive
Average Rate:
Find coverage options that fit your budget.
The insurance savings you expect.
Average Rate:
Enjoy personalized policies, comprehensive coverage & more.
See how much you could save today!
Average Rate:
Drivers who switch their auto insurance and save with State Farm save $764 on average!
Safe Drivers Save with Allstate®
Average Rate:
Get rewarded with savings for having a clean driving record.
What Does Comprehensive Insurance Cover?
What does comprehensive insurance cover is one of the most common questions drivers ask. This protection extends to numerous scenarios that could damage or destroy your vehicle without involving a collision.
Covered Incidents and Examples
| Coverage Type | What It Includes | Real-World Example |
|---|---|---|
| Theft | Full vehicle or stolen parts | Catalytic converter theft, car stolen from parking lot |
| Vandalism | Intentional damage to your vehicle | Keyed paint, smashed windows, spray paint |
| Weather Events | Natural disasters and severe weather | Hail dents, flood damage, tornado damage, hurricane destruction |
| Fire | Vehicle fires from any source | Engine fire, fire from external source, explosion |
| Falling Objects | Items that fall onto your vehicle | Tree branches, rocks, debris from structures |
| Animal Collisions | Hitting or being hit by animals | Deer strikes, collisions with livestock or wildlife |
| Glass Damage | Windshield and window breakage | Rock chips, cracks from debris (often with waived deductible) |
| Civil Unrest | Damage from riots or protests | Riot-related damage, civil disturbance incidents |
Glass Coverage Benefits
Many best comprehensive car insurance policies include special provisions for glass damage. Insurers often waive the deductible for windshield repairs (though not full replacements) to encourage quick fixes that prevent larger cracks. This benefit alone can save you hundreds of dollars and makes comprehensive coverage particularly valuable.
What Comprehensive Insurance Doesn't Cover
Understanding exclusions is equally important. Comprehensive coverage does not protect against:
- Collision damage with other vehicles or objects
- Normal wear and tear or mechanical breakdowns
- Damage from poor maintenance
- Personal belongings stolen from inside your vehicle
- Custom parts or equipment not listed on your policy
- Intentional damage you cause to your own vehicle
- Medical expenses (covered by Personal Injury Protection)
- Damage from driving-related incidents
For collision-related damage, you'll need separate collision coverage. For mechanical issues, consider an extended warranty rather than relying on insurance. Personal items require homeowners or renters insurance for theft coverage.
Comprehensive Coverage Cost and Factors Affecting Premiums
Understanding comprehensive coverage cost helps you budget appropriately and identify savings opportunities. The average cost for full coverage car insurance (including comprehensive) is approximately $208 per month or $2,496 annually in 2026. Comprehensive coverage alone typically represents 10-20% of full coverage premiums, making it relatively affordable compared to collision and liability coverage.
Average Costs by State
Insurance costs vary dramatically by location due to regional risks like theft rates, weather patterns, and local repair costs:
| State Category | Monthly Cost | Annual Cost | Key Risk Factors |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest Cost (Vermont, Maine, Wyoming) | $128-$131 | $1,536-$1,572 | Low theft rates, minimal weather risks, rural areas |
| National Average | $208 | $2,496 | Balanced risk profile |
| Highest Cost (Nevada, Louisiana, Florida) | $311-$335 | $3,732-$4,020 | High theft rates, severe weather, elevated claims frequency |
Key Factors Affecting Your Premiums
Several elements determine your comprehensive car insurance rates:
Location and Regional Risks: Urban areas with high theft rates cost more than rural communities. States prone to hurricanes, tornadoes, or hail see elevated premiums. Your ZIP code significantly impacts pricing—sometimes by 50% or more.
Vehicle Make and Model: Expensive vehicles cost more to insure due to higher repair and replacement costs. Cars frequently targeted by thieves (like certain Honda and Toyota models for their catalytic converters) face higher comprehensive premiums. Compact SUVs like the RAV4 or CR-V average around $214 monthly for full coverage—approximately 14% below the national average.
Driver Profile and History: While comprehensive coverage isn't tied to your driving record like collision coverage, your overall risk profile matters. Drivers with poor credit pay significantly more—around $276+ monthly compared to $193 for excellent credit. Recent comprehensive claims can increase future rates by 10-25%.
Coverage Limits and Deductibles: Your comprehensive insurance deductible directly impacts premiums. A $1,000 deductible can reduce comprehensive costs by 40% or more compared to a $200 deductible, while a $500 deductible offers a balance between savings and out-of-pocket costs.
Comparing Insurance Providers
Different insurance companies price comprehensive coverage differently. According to 2026 data, companies like GEICO and Progressive offer lower average rates ($3,774-$3,805 annually for full coverage) compared to Farmers or Allstate ($7,468-$8,244). Shopping around can save you over $2,000 annually for identical coverage—that's why comparing quotes is essential when searching for cheap car insurance in 2026.
When Do I Need Comprehensive Insurance?
Determining do i need comprehensive insurance depends on your vehicle's status, value, and your financial situation. While this coverage remains optional in most states, certain circumstances make it mandatory or highly advisable.
Required Situations
Financed or Leased Vehicles: Lenders and leasing companies almost always require comprehensive coverage to protect their financial interest. If you're making payments on your vehicle, expect this as a non-negotiable requirement until you pay off the loan. Failing to maintain required coverage can result in force-placed insurance at much higher rates or even loan default.
GAP Insurance Requirements: If you carry gap insurance, you'll need comprehensive coverage. GAP insurance pays the difference between your vehicle's ACV and your remaining loan balance after a total loss—but only if you have comprehensive and collision coverage in place.
When Comprehensive Makes Financial Sense
Even when optional, comprehensive coverage makes sense in several scenarios:
Newer or High-Value Vehicles: If your car is worth $5,000 or more, comprehensive coverage typically justifies its cost. Replacing or repairing a valuable vehicle out-of-pocket creates significant financial burden, making the protection worthwhile.
High-Risk Areas: Living in regions prone to severe weather, high theft rates, or abundant wildlife increases your comprehensive claim likelihood. If you live in Florida (hurricanes), the Midwest (tornadoes and hail), or areas with frequent deer collisions, this coverage provides crucial protection.
Limited Emergency Savings: If replacing your vehicle would create financial hardship, comprehensive coverage acts as essential financial protection. Even if your car is older but you lack savings to replace it, maintaining coverage makes sense.
Peace of Mind: Some drivers value the security of comprehensive coverage regardless of vehicle age. If the premium represents a small portion of your budget and eliminates worry about unpredictable events, it's worth keeping.
Understanding Comprehensive Insurance Deductibles
Your comprehensive insurance deductible is the amount you pay out-of-pocket before insurance covers the remaining claim cost. This choice significantly impacts both your premiums and potential claim expenses.
How Deductibles Work
When you file a comprehensive claim, you pay your deductible first, then the insurer covers remaining costs up to your vehicle's ACV. For example:
- Scenario: A hailstorm causes $2,500 in damage to your vehicle
- Your deductible: $500
- Insurance pays: $2,000
- You pay: $500
Comprehensive deductibles apply per incident, not annually like health insurance. Each separate claim requires you to pay the deductible again. Importantly, your comprehensive and collision deductibles can differ—you might choose a $500 comprehensive deductible and $1,000 collision deductible based on your risk assessment.
Common Deductible Amounts
The most common comprehensive insurance deductible is $500, but insurers typically offer options from $100 to $2,000:
Choosing Your Deductible Amount
Several factors should guide your deductible decision:
Emergency Savings: Choose a deductible you can comfortably afford to pay. If you only have $1,000 in savings, a $2,000 deductible creates financial risk. Your deductible should represent no more than what you could cover without hardship.
Vehicle Value: On older vehicles, high deductibles might approach the car's value, making comprehensive coverage less practical. For a $3,000 vehicle with a $1,000 deductible, maximum payout is only $2,000—assess whether this makes financial sense.
Risk Tolerance and Claim History: If you've filed multiple comprehensive claims recently or live in high-risk areas, lower deductibles provide more protection. Conversely, if you've been claim-free for years, higher deductibles save money long-term.
Premium Savings Calculation: Compare actual premium differences between deductible levels. If increasing your deductible from $500 to $1,000 saves $200 annually, you'd break even after 2.5 years without a claim ($500 additional deductible ÷ $200 annual savings).
Learn more about car insurance deductibles to make the most informed decision for your situation.
When to Drop Comprehensive Coverage
Understanding when to drop comprehensive coverage can save you hundreds of dollars annually without sacrificing necessary protection. However, this decision requires careful analysis of your vehicle's value and your financial circumstances.
The 10% Rule
The most widely recommended guideline: consider dropping comprehensive coverage when annual premiums exceed 10% of your vehicle's actual cash value.
Example: If your car is worth $4,000 and comprehensive coverage costs $450 annually (including collision), you're paying 11.25% of the vehicle's value for coverage. At this threshold, self-insuring often makes more financial sense.
Vehicle Value Thresholds
Most experts recommend evaluating comprehensive coverage when your vehicle's ACV falls below $2,000-$5,000, especially after accounting for your deductible:
| Vehicle Value | Deductible | Maximum Insurance Payout | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|---|
| $5,000+ | Any | Substantial benefit | Keep coverage |
| $3,000-$5,000 | $500-$1,000 | Moderate benefit | Evaluate based on premium cost |
| $2,000-$3,000 | $500+ | Minimal benefit | Likely drop unless premiums very low |
| Under $2,000 | Any | Very limited benefit | Drop coverage |
Additional Factors to Consider
Vehicle Age: While age alone isn't definitive, cars over 10-20 years old often fall into lower value ranges where comprehensive becomes less worthwhile. However, well-maintained classic or collectible vehicles may warrant coverage regardless of age.
Regional Risks: If you live in areas with high theft rates, severe weather, or abundant wildlife, comprehensive coverage may justify its cost even on older vehicles. Conversely, rural areas with minimal risks make dropping coverage more sensible.
Personal Financial Situation: Your ability to replace or repair your vehicle out-of-pocket is crucial. If your car represents essential transportation and you lack savings to replace it, keeping affordable comprehensive coverage provides important protection.
Premium Cost: If comprehensive coverage only costs $100-200 annually, it may be worth keeping for peace of mind even on an older vehicle. However, if it costs $400-500 or more, dropping coverage typically makes financial sense on vehicles under $4,000 in value.
Alternatives to Dropping Coverage
Before eliminating comprehensive coverage entirely, consider these options:
- Increase your deductible to $1,000 or higher to reduce premiums while maintaining protection
- Shop for better rates among different insurers—prices vary significantly
- Remove collision coverage only while keeping comprehensive, since comprehensive is typically cheaper and protects against more unpredictable risks
Remember that once you drop comprehensive coverage, you can't file claims for theft, vandalism, or weather damage. Only drop coverage if you're financially prepared to handle these potential losses.
Is Comprehensive Insurance Worth It?
The question "is comprehensive insurance worth it" depends entirely on your specific circumstances. This coverage provides valuable protection, but its worth varies based on vehicle value, location risks, and personal finances.
When Comprehensive Insurance Is Worth It
Newer Vehicles (0-5 Years Old): For newer cars, comprehensive coverage almost always makes sense. These vehicles have substantial value, and repair costs often run high. The relatively low comprehensive premium (compared to the vehicle's value) provides significant protection. Combined with financing requirements, comprehensive coverage is essential for new vehicles.
High-Value Vehicles: Any car worth $5,000 or more typically justifies comprehensive coverage. The potential loss from theft or major weather damage far exceeds the annual premium cost. For vehicles worth $15,000+, comprehensive coverage is a clear financial win.
High-Risk Locations: If you live in areas prone to severe weather (hurricanes, tornadoes, hail), high auto theft rates, or regions with frequent animal collisions, comprehensive coverage provides crucial protection against likely events. Florida, Louisiana, and Midwest tornado-belt residents particularly benefit from this coverage.
Leased or Financed Vehicles: Beyond being required, comprehensive coverage makes sense financially when you owe more than the vehicle's worth. Pair it with gap insurance for complete protection if your vehicle is totaled.
Limited Savings: If replacing your vehicle would create financial hardship, comprehensive coverage acts as essential protection. For many families, losing their vehicle without insurance payout would be devastating—making the premium a worthwhile investment.
When You Might Skip Comprehensive Coverage
Older, Low-Value Vehicles: Once your vehicle's value drops below $2,000-3,000 and you can afford to replace it, comprehensive coverage typically costs more than its potential benefit over time.
Significant Emergency Savings: If you have substantial savings dedicated to vehicle replacement and your car is older, you're effectively self-insured and can skip comprehensive coverage.
Very Low Risk Areas: In rural areas with minimal theft, limited severe weather, and few animal collision risks, comprehensive claims become unlikely. Combined with an older vehicle, dropping coverage might make sense.
Making Your Decision
Consider these factors when evaluating is comprehensive insurance worth it for your situation:
Calculate your vehicle's current value using tools like Kelley Blue Book, then compare this to your annual comprehensive premium plus deductible. If a total loss would cost significantly more out-of-pocket than several years of premiums, comprehensive coverage is worth it. However, if premiums approach 10% of vehicle value or the maximum payout (value minus deductible) seems minimal, reconsider the coverage.
Most importantly, explore options with best auto insurance companies 2026 to ensure you're getting competitive rates. Shopping around takes minimal time but can save hundreds of dollars annually while maintaining the coverage you need.
Frequently Asked Questions About Comprehensive Car Insurance
What is comprehensive car insurance and how does it differ from collision coverage?
Comprehensive car insurance explained: This coverage protects your vehicle from non-collision damages like theft, vandalism, weather events, fire, falling objects, and animal strikes. Collision coverage, by contrast, handles damage from impacts with other vehicles or objects. Comprehensive covers events beyond your control as a driver, while collision covers driving-related accidents. Both are optional unless required by a lender, and you can purchase one without the other depending on your needs.
How much does comprehensive coverage typically cost?
Comprehensive coverage cost varies significantly by location, vehicle type, and driver profile, but comprehensive typically represents 10-20% of full coverage premiums. The average full coverage insurance (including comprehensive) costs approximately $208 monthly or $2,496 annually in 2026. States like Vermont and Maine see costs around $128-131 monthly, while Nevada and Florida average $311-335 monthly. Your specific rate depends on factors like your ZIP code, vehicle value, credit score, chosen deductible, and local theft or weather risks.
Do I need comprehensive insurance if I own my car outright?
Do i need comprehensive insurance when you own your vehicle depends on its value and your financial situation. While not legally required, comprehensive coverage makes sense if your car is worth $5,000 or more, you live in high-risk areas prone to theft or severe weather, or you cannot afford to replace your vehicle out-of-pocket. However, if your vehicle's value is under $2,000-3,000 and you have adequate savings, dropping comprehensive coverage often makes financial sense since maximum payouts become minimal after deductibles.
How do I choose the right comprehensive insurance deductible?
Choose a comprehensive insurance deductible you can comfortably afford to pay during a claim, typically ranging from $100 to $2,000. The most common choice is $500, balancing affordable premiums with manageable out-of-pocket costs. Higher deductibles ($1,000+) reduce premiums by 30-40% but require adequate emergency savings. Consider your vehicle's value, claim history, local risks, and potential premium savings when deciding. Calculate how long you'd need to stay claim-free to justify a higher deductible's premium savings.
When should I drop comprehensive coverage on an older vehicle?
When to drop comprehensive coverage: Apply the 10% rule—consider dropping coverage when annual premiums exceed 10% of your vehicle's actual cash value. Most experts recommend dropping comprehensive when your vehicle's value falls below $2,000-$5,000, especially after accounting for deductibles. A $2,000 car with a $500 deductible provides only $1,500 maximum payout, often not worth the annual premium. However, keep coverage if premiums remain very low ($100-200 annually), you lack savings for replacement, or you live in very high-risk areas.